Free tool
Rent vs buy calculator
Comparing an EMI with a rent cheque answers the wrong question. This compares what you would be worth at the end of each path — buying with a loan, or renting and investing the difference.
Assumptions — these decide the answer
Renting and investing comes out ahead by ₹28,76,085
After 10 years, on these assumptions. Buying does not pull ahead within this period.
If you buy — worth after 10y
₹95,60,641
Home ₹1,43,26,782 less selling costs and ₹44,79,605 of loan
If you rent — worth after 10y
₹1,24,36,727
Down payment, buying costs and monthly savings, invested
Your EMI
₹55,541
Cash needed upfront
₹22,40,000
Interest paid
₹47,44,487
Rent paid instead
₹41,44,934
| After | If you buy | If you rent | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | ₹48,51,549 | ₹64,31,739 | −₹15,80,190 |
| 10 years | ₹95,60,641 | ₹1,24,36,727 | −₹28,76,085 |
Estimates for planning only, not financial advice. Lenders may round figures slightly differently.
Why the EMI-versus-rent comparison misleads
“The EMI is ₹55,541 and rent is ₹25,000, so renting is cheaper” ignores that part of every EMI buys you equity. The reverse — “rent is money down the drain” — ignores that the down payment, the stamp duty and every rupee of the monthly difference could have been invested instead.
Both sides are treated the same way here:
- Buying ends with the home's value, less selling costs and any loan left, plus anything invested in months when renting would have cost more.
- Renting ends with the upfront cash invested from day one, plus the monthly difference invested whenever buying would have cost more.
What actually decides it
Two numbers do most of the work: how fast the property appreciates, and what your money would earn invested instead. On the example above — a ₹80,00,000 home, 20% down, ₹25,000 rent, 6% appreciation against a 10% return — renting ends ₹28,76,085 ahead after ten years.
Nudge appreciation to 9% and the investment return down to 8%, and buying wins by ₹34,92,181 over the same decade. Neither figure is truth; they are assumptions, which is exactly why they sit in the calculator where you can change them.
The third number is how long you stay. Over three years the same purchase is ₹12,18,793 behind, because stamp duty, registration and brokerage — ₹6,40,000 here — are paid on day one and recovered only slowly.
What the model leaves out
Stated plainly, because they matter:
- Tax deductions on the home loan. They depend on which regime you are in and change with Budgets. Claiming them makes buying look somewhat better than shown here.
- Forced saving. An EMI is paid whether or not you feel like it; the renter's investing only happens if it actually happens. This model assumes perfect discipline, which flatters renting.
- Security and freedom. No landlord ending the tenancy, against the freedom to move for a job next year. Neither belongs in a spreadsheet, and both belong in the decision.
- Rental yield reality. In most Indian cities rent is 2-3% of the property value a year, which is what makes renting competitive on paper in the first place.
If you do buy, the EMI calculator shows what prepayments save, and how much of your salary should go to EMIs covers the ceiling worth holding yourself to.
Questions people ask
How many years do I need to stay for buying to make sense?
On typical Indian assumptions, rarely under five years and often closer to seven to ten. Stamp duty, registration and brokerage are paid upfront and selling costs again at the end, so a short stay pays both without time to recover them.
What appreciation rate should I assume?
Be conservative and test a range. Property does not appreciate uniformly — location and timing dominate — and a rate you cannot justify is how a calculator tells you what you wanted to hear.
Does it include tax benefits on a home loan?
No, deliberately. They depend on the old or new regime and change with Budgets. If you do claim them, buying comes out better than this shows.
Is renting really 'throwing money away'?
Rent buys somewhere to live, the same as interest on a loan buys the use of someone's money. On this model roughly half of an early EMI is interest — also not building equity. What matters is the whole picture, which is what this compares.
More free tools: EMI calculator · SIP calculator · Goal savings calculator · Emergency fund calculator · Rental yield calculator · Savings rate calculator · Life in weeks
Whichever you choose, track it monthly
Becom's budget planner carries rent or an EMI forward every month, keeps investments separate from spending, and shows what you are actually saving.
Start your free trialEvery feature free for 30 days · No card required